Earlier in the week Arianna Huffington claimed that at a 2001 party Sen. John McCain told her he did not vote for George Bush in the election. McCain heavily disputed the account but now actors Bradley Whitford & Richard Schiff have given their accounts of the exchange which they claimed to have witnessed.

The actors say when asked if he voted for the President McCain put a finger up in front of his lips and mouthed “No way.” This is a slightly different account from Huffington’s who said McCain was vocal about his vote.